Too early to say Chinese textbooks go viral overseas: expert
專家:教材“出口”英國 現在談“走紅”為時尚早
Chinese education became a recent hit after New York Times’ report on Britain turning to Chinese textbooks to improve math scores. However, experts said that it is still too early to say Chinese textbooks have entered into the western education system.
It is reported that 36 math textbooks of the Shanghai Century Publishing (Group) Co., Ltd will be introduced to Britain by HarperCollins UK, a British publisher. The books will be used in UK primary schools this September. The Guardian, a UK media, positively commented on the amazing Chinese teaching approach of math.
"All this time, Asians have been learning from the Western education system," said Yong Zhao, a professor of education at University of Kansas. "Suddenly, it’s the reverse."
美國堪薩斯大學的趙勇教授表示,“一直以來,亞洲都在借鑒歐洲的教育模式,突然之間,情況就反轉了。”
Like China’s economy, its education is also influencing and changing the world, said Hu Xinhong, a Chinese middle school teacher. Chinese teaching deserves spreading and Chinese should have confidence.
However, some experts suggest looking at this phenomenon objectively.
不過,一些專家說我們應當客觀看待這個現象。
It is still too early to say that teaching materials for Chinese primary and middle schools have entered into the UK education system in a large scale, just because Britain is importing teaching materials from China, said Xiong Bingqi, vice president of the 21st Century Education Research Institute in Beijing.
Chinese math textbooks going out shows advantages in domestic math teaching, but it doesn’t mean Chinese textbooks are superior to western ones or math teaching in China doesn’t need reform, said Chu Chaohui, a researcher of National Institute of Education Sciences.
In fact, introducing Chinese textbooks to the UK this time is a fruit of China-UK exchanges on education. Early in 2014, an education delegation from the UK and 61 math teachers and researchers from Shanghai exchanged visits, boosting further development of math teaching in the UK.
Chinese and western education has its own advantages and disadvantages. The best is to learn from each other’s strong points and offset weaknesses, the middle school teacher Hu believes.